This, I've noticed, has been the reaction most of my friends — who for some reason tend to be musical theater enthusiasts — have had, and it's somewhat flattering to think that bunches of people think of me whenever Mormons come up.
Anyway, to my point. I have the soundtrack. My friends have the soundtrack, and I've suddenly become hugely popular. Especially with "I believe":
"Really?" they ask. "Kolob? Black people in 1978? Getting your own planet?"
What's been wildly funny to me is to see what people unfamiliar with Mormonism laugh at. Like, for example, a little after a minute in, Elder Price proclaims, with pride:
"I believe that the Lord God created the universe.
I believe that He sent His only son to die, for my sins.
And I believe that ancient Jews built boats and sailed to America!
And they laugh! How ridiculous and crazily stupid that sounds to them! Ancient Jews, building boats, and sailing across the Atlantic Ocean!
... and it totally just sailed right past me when I first heard it. Yeah, I thought, that's how the story goes.
They get a lot of things right about Mormons, at least in the music, and most of what they get wrong is either necessary for plot reasons — technically, you switch mission companions several times during your mission — or trivial. But one of those trivial things, for some irrational reason, bothers me much, much more than it should.
In the beginning of "Joseph Smith American Moses," the mission president says, "Well, this is very good, Praise Christ."
The fuck? "Praise Christ"? No Mormon on the planet would ever say that! That just makes Mormon sounds like a bunch of scary cultists!
Oh, wait...